Christmas is a Religious Festivity

Christmas is a religious festivity – us atheists should not recognise it – do you agree?

This was a question posed by NewcastleBoy via twitter a few days ago. I decided I’d answer it here on my blog instead of twitter because it needs more than 140 characters to provide a full explanation.

Firstly, where did the modern day Christian Christmas season and festivities come from? Why was the 25th December chosen as Christmas Day?

There is no evidence that the 25th December was Jesus’ birthday despite this being cited as the reason for that day being chosen (there is no evidence that Jesus ever existed at all, but that’s another story).  Some say the 25th was just a date chosen to commemorate his birthday, much like the Queen of England’s  birthday is celebrated at various dates around the world. It has been said that the 25th was chosen as that is the winter solstice (in the northern hemisphere) or that it coincided with historical Roman festivities. I tend to think that those reasons are most likely; with the church trying to convert the pagans into christians there are definite advantages to just accosting the pagans’ days and rituals and converting them to christian equivalents.

Of course the Jews aren’t very big on Christmas, not recognising Jesus as a god and all that, and one has posted an article (despite the anti-christian rant) on the historical origins of Christmas. There are many more of these on the internet, Christians really should learn about the pagan origins of many of their celebrations and rituals, they might be quite surprised.

So the the origins of Christmas are most likely Roman and pagan festivals accosted by the Christians, but where does that leave modern atheists when it comes to recognising those traditions?

Like many people in Anglo countries (America, UK, Australia, large sections of Europe, etc) many of us are what could be called “Cultural Christians”. In so much that the Christian faith is the biggest (by numbers) of all the many faiths. Many of us, myself included, were raised as Christians and were brought up in an environment where Christmas was a big part of the Christian way of life. So to some extent celebrating Christmas is more of a cultural thing than a Christian thing.

Cultural Judaism is well recognised and many Jews call themselves atheists but still adhere to some of the Jewish rituals. I suspect many Christians are the same, in Guy Harrison’s book 50 Reasons (see my review) he talks about cultural Christians and sees no problem with it.

So to answer the original question. I believe atheists should not recognise Christmas as that in some way condones religion and belief in God.

However, I think these days many people just view Christmas as a time to have a few days off and get together with friends and family and celebrate life and friendship (and drink and eat too much). Christmas can be, and is to many people, celebrated without any reference to religion; barring the word Christmas meaning Christ’s Mass. These days even some non-christian nations celebrate Christmas.

Despite it’s religious overtones, I enjoy the idea behind Christmas as a day to give people presents and to share a table with family and friends, and I’ll still put up a Christmas tree (This years is going to be even more outrageous than last years, stay tuned for some pictures in a few weeks time).

I guess in some ways I’m being hypocritical, celebrating Christmas despite not believing in God or Jesus and being non-religious, but heck it’s fun. Perhaps one day Christmas will become a purely pagan ritual again? We could change the name and still have the day off, drink and eat too much, and have a great time with family and friends. After all that’s all Christmas is to me and many others.

As I have no family here, what little I have are interstate, Christmas day is mainly with friends these days. Despite being on my own I will still be doing the Champagne and Croissant breakfast on the morning of the 25 December.  You are all very welcome to attend, just let me know if you are coming so I have enough bubbles and food on hand. 🙂

But there’s more…

Interestingly, as a child many children are taught by their parents (authority figures) that Santa Claus is real and that he brings them presents (reward for being good) or not if they’ve been bad (punishment for not-believing). Much like from birth those same children are taught god is real and that he also rewards the good (promise of heaven) and punishes the bad (fear of hell).

Not surprisingly, eventually children learn that Santa is not real, that he is a made up story, that it is highly improbable that he could deliver presents to everyone on the planet. They realise that there is no credible evidence for Santa, so stop believing in him. Surprise surprise nothing bad happens when they stop believing in Santa, they still get presents from their parents, though now they know it’s them, not a mythical being, that provides the presents.

Strangely many of these same children remain believers in a god, despite there being no more credible evidence for a god than there is for a Santa Clause. Very strange indeed. From personal experience, and from what many others have told me, much like when you stop believing in Santa nothing bad happens, nothing bad happens when you stop believing in god(s).

In fact many people are much happier and content when they no longer have to fear or worry about god. It’s actually easier to live life when you no longer have to try to live up to some mythical god(s) expectations.  If you are a believer perhaps you should think about that this Christmas.

So my answer:

Atheists shouldn’t recognise Christmas as a religious festivity, and I don’t.

But what do you think, should non-believers recognise and/or celebrate Christmas?



Filed under atheism

13 responses to “Christmas is a Religious Festivity

  1. Like you, I was raised Christian. However, I reject sense of being a “cultural Christian” completely. I never understood why I want want to go along with any of it. This means that I do not celebrate Christmas. The only issue I have with this is the massive social stigma it carries. Then again, I’m an atheist. Social stigma is something I’ve grown used to.

  2. I respectfully disagree. Christmas was co-opted from pagan solstice holidays. Christmas trees, yule logs, mistletoe- all betray its pagan origins. In the same way, Christmas has been largely secularized by modern society. When I celerbrate Christmas, I keep none of the religious and superstitious trappings, but I think giving gifts is not at all a bad idea and is a lot of fun. In no way, however, should this be construed as an acknowledgement of the Christian nonsense part of the holiday any more than Christians acknowledge the pagan roots of Christmans.

  3. The tree was originally of Pagan origin. I like the tree. I like the whole “Goodwill toward men” mentality. I wish people could be nice all year long. The meanest person I ever met was a Christian.
    Most stores around here have Christmas decorations up well before Halloween. I hate the gift giving and how commercialized Christmas has become. Maybe because I’m not employed. 🙂

  4. Personally I celebrate family. Plus this year, I’ll be celebrating the notion that Christians can’t recognise Christmas as a religious holiday either.

    Jeremiah 10:2-4 “Thus saith the Lord, Learn not the way of the heathen,
    and be not dismayed at the signs of heaven; for the heathen are dismayed
    at them. For the customs of the people are vain: for one cutteth a tree
    out of the forest, the work of the hands of the workman, with the axe.
    They deck it with silver and with gold; they fasten it with nails and
    with hammers, that it move not.”


  5. the chaplain

    I celebrate Christmas as a time to be with family and friends. I like decorating the house with a tree and some secular decorations, but I stay away from the religious-themed stuff. I can’t even remember where the religious decorations are stored!

  6. I personally do the trek up to Newcastle for the Chrissy-NY break, see family, eat too much… the usual. I also sometimes sing carols, not just the santa ones *gasps*

    I just like to sing and be with family. Even if we all have different reasons to be celebrating

  7. I like the parties and the fun. To hell with the religious overtones. I ignore it.

    (sorry about the double post)

  8. In regards to changing the name, Futurama already handled that one. In the year 3000 everybody just calls it xmas, pronounced phonetically.

  9. Sam

    Hey Oz Athiest… thanks for your post! I reckon your on the money in many ways. I don’t celebrate Ramadan because I am not a Muslim. Why would I expect you to celebrate Christmas.

    But I couldn’t disagree with you more on this statement….

    “Much like from birth those same children are taught god is real and that he also rewards the good (promise of heaven) and punishes the bad (fear of hell).”

    This isn’t what Christians believe. Some Catholics are taught this kind of doctrine but Christians have never said that people go to heaven because they are good.

    Anyway… happy new year to you!

  10. Augustusmas would be the correct term.

  11. “This isn’t what Christians believe. Some Catholics are taught this kind of doctrine but Christians have never said that people go to heaven because they are good.”

    That’s right, Sam.
    They say you’re goin’ to heaven if you believe in Hay Zeus EVEN IF YOU ARE a vile, evil, horrible killer/rapist/thief – much the same as other popular theories of god/satan.

  12. Atheists can celebrate Christmas as a cultural holiday.

    However an Atheist could celebrate the birth of Jesus in the same sense that StarWars nerds could celebrate the birth of Luke Skywalker (if known). Jesus was fictional just like so many other characters in popular culture so it seems reasonable (however unlikely) that Jesus could have Atheist fans.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s